Thursday, October 21, 2010

Howard's right on....

To quote Howard Beale in the movie Network  -- We know things are bad, Worse than bad -- they're crazy.

Yes they are.
Howard Beale

The recent onslaught of letters, media coverage and editorials regarding the initiative to recall Village Board Trustee Lisa Stone shows you just how crazy the situation has gotten,   No doubt that Stone is crying foul because letters by residents, some of whom are even in the village board are urging voters to vote yes for Stone's recall on the Nov. 2 ballot.

No doubt cynics will say that some of the letters, written by Village Board Members, may represent an abuse of their position in an effort to sway voters to their side.

To which I say touche.


During the past two Board meetings Stone has stepped down from the dais to speak as a resident and not a trustee.  Her arguments did not change, just her location.  By speaking as a "resident" Stone was able to get more time to once again pontificate her various causes -- OTB, L & L, the 2005 executive session and, of course the old boys club.


Letters to various print and on-line media by trustees Jeff Berman, Jeff Braiman and Board President Elliott Hartstein should not be viewed as abuse of the dais.  They are writing as residents and each has made it quite clear that their views are their own and do not reflect any position associated with the Village Board.

The big difference is their viewpoints are not costing the village money, nor are they delaying village business.  Whether you agree or disagree with the letters, keep in mind that they, like Stone, are entitled to their "citizen" opinions.

If you think their opinions are off base, then you have not been to a Village Board meeting, nor have you watched them on public access.  To no surprise, there are video excerpts of Village Board meetings available.  Like these:  From the Board meetings

It's shenanigans like this that have many Buffalo Grove residents citing another, and more famous, Howard Beale quote -- "I'm as mad as Hell and I'm not gonna take this any more."

Can you blame them?

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

A new beginning...

The routine has gotten out of hand and has become too predicable.

I am, of course, talking about the way Village Board President Elliott Hartstein begins each Village Board Meeting.

Without fail, trustee, oops, I mean President Hartstein always starts the meeting by saying "I'd like to call this meeting of the Buffalo Grove Village Board to order; will you all please rise for the pledge."

Functional, but boring -- and besides, it does not capture the essence of the meetings.  I know, I've read the minutes.

If Hartstein really wanted to start the meetings with a little flair -- one which would truly reflect the nature of the meetings, he should start the meetings by saying:

There is a fifth dimension, beyond that which is known to man.
It is a dimension as vast as space and as timeless as infinity. It is the middle ground between light and shadow, between science and superstition. And, it lies between the pit of man's fears and the summit of his knowledge. This is the dimension of imagination. It is an area which we call the Twilight Zone. 
If you are looking for truth in government, transparency, accuracy -- this says it all.

And Monday night was no different.  It was a meeting that included discussions on landfills, OTB hearings, minutes, visitors from other villages and, of course, information about trustee visits to the rest room.

Welcome to the Twilight Zone.

Whether it's the upcoming full moon (Friday night, folks), a hole in the ozone or the upcoming election -- Monday's Village Board meeting was truly strange.

Why? Take a guess.  As Yogi Berra would say, it was Deja vu all over again.

Now I'm sure someone will post a comment saying I'm too repetitive about the Board meetings.

Well, I guess I am -- but with good reason -- the Village Board meetings have gotten that way.  That's not the result of any "old boys" -- or to be politically correct -- "old persons" club -- but because certain people see the first and third Mondays of the month as the day when they want to air out their dirty laundry.

It's an old and tired antic.

Lisa Stone's accusations every thing is wrong with the Board and the village have gotten old -- and way too predictable -- and  annoying.

Let's see item III -- approval of the minutes -- that means Stoney will once again rip into Village Clerk Jan Sirabian because the minutes don't reflect what's happening -- translation -- Sirabian does not put in all of Stone's rants about everybody and everything -- see, it would make campaign literature.

But wait, folks, Monday was a special night -- we had not, one, but two sets of minutes to vote on.  Stone, of course voted no to the minutes from Oct. 4 meeting, but the agenda also called for approval of the minutes from the Sept. 27 Finance Committee meeting, which Stone was upset about.

But rather than go it alone, Rob Sherman, who has suddenly become interested in the meeting minutes, addressed the board challenging the minutes.  In fact, Sherman said he contacted the Attorney General's office and that it was mortified that the minutes were not more specific.

Interesting, Village Attorney William Raysa also contacted the Attorney General's office and was told that the minutes were OK.

So who you going to believe?  No doubt Sherman contacted the Attorney General's office, but his interpretation may be off.  After all, according to his web site,  Sirabian lost village board meetings.   I think he meant minutes and no, she did not, what is missing is a tape of an executive session.  Attention to details.  Sherman also said the Attorney General "condemns" the minutes.  From the nature of his and Raysa's reports, there may be an air of concern, but not condemnation.

The highlight, if you want to call it that, was Stone's charges that during the recess at the Oct. 4 meeting, several trustees had the nerve to stand together and talk and when she came out the rest room they dispersed.

Let's see, a public meeting, a recess in a public place, and members of a board talking -- it seems as though there are allegations of a violation to the Open Meetings  Act.  Right.  Given the information presented by Miz Stone, it seems as though the Board should have realized its grievous behavior and accompanied her to the rest room. On second thought...

And for who knows how many times someone came to address the board from outside the village. Why?  another expert who seemingly has nothing better to do than support Stone.  Let's see, they've come from Lincolnshire, Westchester, Vernon Hills and who knows, maybe ALF will show up from Melmac to discuss the ozone layer.  Seems to me an alien would fit right in.

For the second meeting in a row Stone stepped down from dais to address the board as a resident and not trustee.  Last time I checked, trustees had to be residents, so aside from a stunt to gain more Ch. 6 time, all that Stone accomplishes is delaying the residents who wanted to speak to the board.  But it's not about the residents, is it?

So our trip to the Twilight Zone is becoming a regular routine -- complete with the usual acrimonious remarks directed toward just about everyone in the dais.

As usual, she wants everyone to be quiet when she speaks, but thinks nothing of interrupting anyone else when they speak. When Hartstein tried to keep her in  order, she said "President Hartstein, you're too much."

Hartstein too much?  What's too much is Stone's incessant accusations against anyone who disagrees with her.  What's too much is the use of village time for personal agendas and campaigns.  What's too much is the lack of respect for village staff and volunteers. What's too much is the time being spent in "the Twilight Zone."

In the meantime, Hartstein needs to not only work on his opening, but his closing as well.,  In place of the placid "is there a motion to adjourn.." -- he could easily say..
Obscure metaphysical explanation to cover a phenomenon, reasons dredged out of the shadows to explain away that which cannot be explained. Call it parallel planes or just insanity. Whatever it is, you just found it in the Twilight Zone.










Saturday, October 16, 2010

This could be interesting

Well it's almost showtime.

Yes boys and girls, once again the men and women of the Buffalo Grove Village Board will meet to discuss operations of the Village and to, more than likely, hear Trustee Lisa Stone pontificate on the hole in the ozone layer, which has apparently impacted her colleagues on the Board etc. etc. etc.

Let's not forget that the Nov. 2 election is just a bit more than two weeks away, so every bit of time in front of the camera is valuable.

Included, as always, on the agenda are the highly popular "Reports for Trustees" during which time most trustees report on board-related activities that they have been involved with as part of the role as trustee.

Trustee Beverly Sussman's report will include information about a "Why I Love Buffalo Grove" Contest.  The idea was brought to light a little more than a year ago when Board President Elliott Hartstein reported to the Board how he met a young resident, Rachel Becker, at the 2009 Buffalo Grove Days during which she suggested the village have such a contest.

Great idea.  Rachel seems appreciative of the village, polite, and articulate, which puts her way ahead of some trustees.

So what happened to the idea?  Another resident caught the Sept. 8, 2009 on video and also thought it was a good idea and put together a proposal for a comprehensive contest for the village.  The intent, according to the original proposal, was to foster as many relationships as possible in the village.  For example, the village could work with the school districts, Historical Society, business community, park district and other organizations.

The intent, according to the author, is to, in a perfect world, have participants develop a project that is grade appropriate and encourage them to do school-based, or school-quality research.  The developer noted that it would be great if  participants worked with their teacher so perhaps, the project would benefit the participant if he/she was working in conjunction with the learning standards established by the Illinois State Board of Education (ISBE).

The developer is an educator and also happens to be a blogger.

I developed the plan.

So why blog about it?  A cheesy effort to be self-serving?  A way to win the hearts of school children?  A hint that I may run for the Board (ah, no...)?

No.  It's a preemptive strike, if you will, at critics who may think this was done to boost my visibility to the board or to discredit Stone.

It was done because I think it's a good idea.  Period.

There are no hidden agendas, not motives or any plans other than the obvious.

A little background ---  I submitted the original concept to Hartstein and former Village Manager Bill Brimm who suggested I run it past Sussman as she is a former school teacher.  In April, I met with Brimm, Sussman, and Trustee Jeff Braiman to discuss the idea.  One other trustee was dying to get into the meeting and did so by asking a lame question of Brimm and then asked what the meeting was about.  She was told -- an essay contest.  I don't think she believed Brimm (this is news?) and sauntered away.

Since that time I have exchanged emails with Sussman, Hartstein and Deputy Village Manager Ghida Neukirch about the plan and was delighted when I received an email from Neukirch informing me that the proposal would be discussed by the Board at the Oct. 18 meeting.

So, as Mr. Portokalos would say, there you go.

There is nothing else to it.  True most of my blogs have focused on the upheaval at Board meetings brought on by Miz Quixote.

But it is important to note that there are (myself excluded at this point) residents who want to do things for the village on a volunteer basis.

Not everything needs to focus on one trustee who has a limited personal agenda.

So not only am I pleased the Board will discuss it Monday night, but I'll get to meet Rachel as well.

As I said, she seems to love the village, is polite, and articulate -- maybe she'll want to run for the Board.  If nothing else, they'd have to finish early so she can get home before curfew.

And who knows, there may be an opening soon.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Minute argument over minutes....

There seems to be a lot of concern about the quality of the minutes.  Trustee Lisa Stone has voted against the minutes almost from the time she joined the Board.

But why?  She claims she wants the minutes to reflect more of what is said at the meeting.  Translation -- she wants her comments front and center.

At the Oct. 4 meeting, she once again ripped Village Clerk Jan Sirabian for not doing the job the way she thinks it should be done.

You'd think Sirabian would know.  After all, she has been village clerk for 32 years.

Stone cited public comments and concern about the minutes, especially those from the Sept. 27  Finance Committee meeting.

Public comments?  How about those of Rob Sherman on his web site who calls for Sirabian's retirement from the position.  In fact, Sherman said he'd be willing to run for the post, but, according to his web site,

It's a lousy, boring job.  I don't want to be Buffalo Grove Village Clerk, but we need a change.

and


I hope I don't have to be the next Buffalo Grove Village Clerk, but it could be a lot of fun to sit in on those Executive Sessions and find out what's really going on behind those closed doors.


Sherman thinks someone who has been in the post as long as Sirabian has lost the competitive edge, thinks someone in office that long begins to lose things and thinks they own the office.

News flash -- Jan Sirabian isn't perfect -- no one is -- including Mr. Sherman.  Perhaps Ms. Sirabian has made some miscues, but Mr. Sherman has made his as well.

It may be a lousy, boring job, but Sirabian has done it well.

Are Buffalo Grove's minutes that bad because they don't give Ms. Stone her due?  Minutes are to reflect decisions as a matter of record.

But rather than do a point-by-point breakdown comparing minutes, let me paraphrase an old saying -- "A link is worth a thousand words."

Take a look.  You'll find that the work being done in Buffalo Grove is just fine.  As it has been for more than 30 years.

http://www.cityhpil.com/pdf/ccMinutes/ccminutes091310.pdf

http://www.vah.com/assets/1/agendas_and_minutes/92010bt.pdf

http://www.northbrook.il.us/Government/BoardsCommissions/Minutes/Board/Board_08-31-10.pdf

http://www.vernonhills.org/UserFiles/File/Minutes_2007/09212010%20Board%20Minutes.pdf

http://ci.sheboygan.wi.us/Clerks/CommitteeMeetings/Minutes/CommonCouncil/2010/09-07-2010.pdf

Saturday, October 9, 2010

The Board needs to get Hawkish....


The declaration by Village Board President Elliott Hartstein that a timer be used to keep the Village Board meetings moving along is a unique idea.


But it's only a start.


The board meetings have taken on a flair of another significant Monday night event -- Monday Night Football. If the Board wanted to attract more viewers, it should adapt to the market and make their meetings more like Monday night football.


Howard Cosell
It's too bad it can;t be done like MNF was done in its hay day with Howard, Frank and Dandy Don. Can you imagine Howard Cosell   engaging Lisa Stone? 


But we'll never know.  The reality is the Board has adopted some rules designed to keep the meetings going.  Time limits are not unusual -- many village boards, school boards, park board, etc. have time restrictions.  Given the nature of things with the Buffalo Grove Village Board, most people think they are designed to silence trustee Lisa Stone.  The bottom line is the rule applies to all trustees.


The enforcement of the time limits by appointing a time keeper (village staff member Art Malinowski) puts a new twist on Village Board meetings -- time management.  Several times during the meeting Stone was heard prompting Melanowski when to start her time and reminding Village Board President Elliott Hartstein how much time she had at any given time.  


The focus on time management  reminded me of a football game, which made me think that the Village Board meetings have become a governmental version of Monday Night Football.  


What's next?  Referees?  Video replays? Cheerleaders?  


Hawk Harrelson
How about announcers?  Since the aforementioned Howard Cosell is in the big broadcast booth in the sky, my suggestion is to have Melanowski joined in the booth by White Sox announcer Ken "the Hawk" Harrelson.


Why not?  He's used to disagreements -- just look at Kenny Williams and Ozzie Guillen -- that's similar to Hartstein and Stone.  He's used to incessant rants. He's used to bizarreness.  


And to make things easier, he would not have to learn any new lingo.  For example these classic "Harrelsonisms":

  • At the start of a meeting:  "Time to cinch it up and hunker down"  or "Sit Back, Relax, and Strap it Down!" 
  • When the exchanges between trustees gets acrimonious:   "Mercy!"
  • When Hartstein tries to keep Stone in order:  "Zone 'em in, Reel 'em in, and light her up"
  • When the Board tries to regain focus after a Stone tirade:  "But the damage is done"
  • When someone tries to correct Stone:  "That's trouble" 
  • When Stone tries to insist that she's right:  "Lookin' for it, got it, couldn't do nothing with it" 
  • When trustee Steve Trilling sets the record straight:  "Give 'em a thrill"
  • When Stone takes on Village Clerk Jan Sirabian: "That's trouble"
  • At the end of yet another long, drawn out meeting (with one slight modification):  "And this one...is OVA!!"
So what might he say after the Nov. 2 election -- especially if Stone is recalled?  It could be...with some minor editing...
  • She gone. 
or, 
  • You can put her off the booooooooooooooaaaaaaard...YEEEEEEEEEEEEEES!" 

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Silence on the lam

Trustee Lisa Stone revealed at  Monday's Village Board meeting that it's not only what she says that is offensive, arrogant, disrespectful and otherwise demeaning -- it's what she does not say.

In fact, her silence is perhaps most insulting to the people she should care about  -- but does not.  The men and women who work for the village.

Case in point.  Fire Chief Terry Vavra addressed the Board regarding the "ISO Rating" -- the insurance rating of the village's fire department, he detailed the success the village has had.  Buffalo Grove continues to have an ISO rating of 2 -- which is excellent. Only five departments in the state have an ISO rating of 1, so an rating of 2 is pretty damn good.

It's not, as Vavra pointed out, just a departmental rating--  three categories factor into the final rating -- the fire department, the water operation, and communications operations.  The village did exceptionally well -- Out of 50 possible points, the fire department scored 36.12 points; the water score was 39.12 out of 40 and the communications rating was an equally impressive 9.8 out of 10.

Nice numbers.  If you wondering why the fire department did not score higher, Vavra says proximity was a factor -- which means if the village had more fire stations it would likely improve out score, but not guarantee an ISO rating of 1.

Perhaps the most telling remark Vavra made was that it was "not the fire department that got the rating, it was the village."  Great job, chief.

The village -- as in the staff working together to keep the excellence associated with the village in tact.  Granted, it's not perfect, but comments by several trustees expressed interest in what it would take to improve the rating to a 1 and improve things for the entire village.

What we did not hear were any comments from Stone.  No questions, no praise, no interest.  Nothing. Nada. Zippo.

Ask yourself why.  The answer, as shown by what transpired at the meeting is simple -- there was nothing "in it" for her.  It seems as though Stone cannot stand when someone else -- staff, residents, colleagues on the board makes a positive contribution to the community.

That may be why she rips the B.G. Days Committee (aside the fact that she doesn't like many of the members), or the efforts of the Fire Department's "Pink  Heals" effort, or the efforts of the schools to put on drug awareness program (she was, however, quick to rip their efforts to promote them).

The silence is, in this case, not deafening.  It's as loud as can be.  It's loud enough to tell everyone that Stone is only interested in her agenda and if you don't bow down and embrace it, she unleashes her venomous verbiage.

She continues to say that the "whole community" wants to know why the board didn't do what she wanted them to do.

Whole community following Lisa Stone? Watch the video and maybe you'll find out why the "Whole Community" is not following Lisa Stone.

You may wonder why Village President Elliott Hartstein has become curt.  To every action, there's a reaction and Stone's actions have done little, correction, nothing, to foster any positive reactions by other board members.

What her actions have done is given the village a black eye.

What her actions have done is made a mockery of municipal government.

What her actions have done has raised the ire of the community.   Whether it's the whole community or not remains to be seen.

We'll know by Nov. 2.

And Lisa Stone won't have anything constructive to say.  Which wouldn't be the first time.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Daily Oral Language -- Part II

No one likes disappointment.

So I had to feel sorry for Gus Portokalos when he found out that two words being bantered around at Village Board meetings did not, in fact, come from Greek.



"You know, I thought the word community came from the work meaning common, as in what we all had together," he said.  But no.  It's from the Latin.

The meaning, however, doesn't change.  Check it out and you'll find that a key component in the definition is unified or common.


So when Lisa Stone rants on about how the "community wants to know" or how the "I think the community needs to know" she should consider the meaning -- unified.   It's amazing to me how she carries on about the needs of the community, yet she does little to work on behalf of the entire community.  Nor, as a matter of fact, does she check the pulse of the community.  It's as though she is a community of one.  This has been evident in how she works with her colleagues on the Board who, as she was, elected by the community.  Stone portrays herself as knowing the pulse of the community.

Listening to her at the last Board meeting, which was Sept. 13, you'd think the community is unified over the Land and Lakes landfill and the executive session from 2005. How does she know?  Has she surveyed the community?  Of course not.  She is so bent on her personal attacks on village staff and colleagues that she sees little in the benefits of a unified effort.


"So, it's one word, what other word do you want to know," Portokalos  asked.  "Citizen," I said.  "Ach, I believe the word citizen comes from the Greek..."  Sorry, I informed him, it does not.

But it's one of Stoney's favorite words.  You know, how she's heard from citizens about just about everything, well, everything that's on her personal agenda.  Like the Invisible Children group, which contacted her. They wanted to have a fund raiser at the Village Rotary Green.  No one knew about it until the Recall Committee had a rally there -- then, and only then, did Stone bring it to the Board.

Was this working in the best interest of the citizens?  Was it a way to work for the community?

Nope.

Portokalos shook his head.  "You know, I don't think the word stone comes from the Greek, so, there you go."

Gus, I told him, it's not me who has to go.